Posted by: Randy Allgaier | March 22, 2008

John McCain- Hagee, Purim and a Sunni Sh’ia Identity Crisis

After Senator Barack Obama made his historic, intelligent, mesmerizing and frank speech about race in American this week, I mused about whether the American people are able to live up to the Senator’s expectations of us to be adult, intelligent and engage in loftier debate in politics rather than the usual down and dirty politics of destruction. Of course the jury is still out and I hope the American people are ready for some intelligence.

This week they didn’t get it from the heir apparent to the Republican nomination, Senator John McCain. Three particularly egregious gaffes that made his campaign seem offensive, out of touch and not well educated on Iraq- the issue that is the cornerstone of his campaign.

Senator John McCain mistakenly said Tuesday that Iran was allowing al-Qaeda fighters into the country to be trained and returned to Iraq; he expressed concern about Iran’s rising sway in the Mideast and said, “Al-Qaeda is going back into Iran and is receiving training and are coming back into Iraq from Iran.” Iran is a predominantly Shiite Muslim country and has been at pains to close its borders to al-Qaeda fighters of the rival Sunni sect. The Senator’s comments made no sense. Iran has been accused by the United States of funding, training and arming Iraqi Shiite militants in their uprising against the U.S. But there has been no evidence that al-Qaeda has benefited from Iranian assistance.

He made the comments Tuesday at a news conference in Jordan; he made similar comments earlier to Hugh Hewitt, an American radio talk-show host.

But what was more embarrassing was that at a press conference it was only after Senator Joe Lieberman (I-CT) who was traveling with McCain, stepped forward to whisper in the candidate’s ear, McCain said: “I’m sorry; the Iranians are training the extremists, not al-Qaeda. Not al-Qaeda. I’m sorry.”

“Not only is Senator McCain wrong on Iraq once again, but he showed he either doesn’t understand the challenges facing Iraq and the region or is willing to ignore the facts on the ground,” said Karen Finney the Democratic National Committee’s communications director.

Senator Obama, in a speech marking the fifth anniversary of the Iraq War, criticized Senator McCain, saying the Republican presidential candidate had confused Iran and Al Qaeda and Sunnis and Shiites and maybe that confusion led him to vote to go to war in Iraq. A senior foreign policy adviser to Senator Obama, Susan Rice, yesterday told the Sun, “It’s very bizarre.” She noted that Mr. McCain had “made the same statement three times in as many days. Surely he must know, as Senator Lieberman reminded him, that Iran is not engaged with Al Qaeda in Iraq. I don’t know if he is confused, or is he cynically trying to conflate Al Qaeda and Iran as Cheney and Bush did Al Qaeda and Iraq in 2002 and 2003?”

Whatever the case, Senator McCain’s confusion leads one to believe that he really doesn’t have a very good grasp of the international tension the complexities of the Arab world and the millennial old dynamics in this part of the world. It was precisely this lack of understanding, in addition to lies and deceit that got us into this mess to begin with.

I truly hope the American people do not mix up the experience of being a war hero with that of being commander in chief- which requires not only an understanding of the military, but an understanding of the world, international relations, and diplomacy. It is clear that Senator McCain doesn’t understand this more inclusive role for the President- and defines it in terms that are purely military each time that he says that the current surge is working. True there may be less violence (it does seem odd to measure success in terms of levels of violence from horrific to horrible) but the whole point of the surge was to give the Iraqi government breathing room to make political progress. That has failed. Simple logic tells one that if the reason for an action has not occurred, the action has in fact failed. But Senator McCain can only look at this in the prism of military success not political and diplomatic success. That is troubling.

Next is the issue of Pastor John Hagee’s endorsement of Senator McCain. While Senator Obama has had to endure a firestorm over remarks of his pastor Jeremiah Wright- remarks taken out of the context of decades of a ministry that has been universally respected in religious and secular circles. Many prominent Chicagoans attend Trinity United Church of Christ including, Senator Obama, Oprah Winfrey and many Chicago politicos- white and black. Wright’s comments were despicable and I rebuke them, but they have unfairly tarnished a ministry praised for its work on behalf of the homeless, the sick, those that Christ told us to minister to. The ministry as a whole has not been examined and there would be little to criticize if the media examined its history.   Besides many of the leaders of the religious right said that the American people brought 9/11 onto ourselves- there wasn’t a great uproar aimed at Mr. Falwell or Mr. Robertson.

But Mr. McCain has sought endorsement from a man who has called Catholicism the “Great Whore” and who, while being a staunch supporter of Israel and is supportive of a war with Iran, has very disturbing motives for both of those positions. Of course any action against Iran is totally absurd. Our military is stretched and we have done enough damage in the region- it is a time to work diplomacy in the region not empire militarism.

Reverend Hagee’s reason for supporting Israel and a war with Iran is based on his desire to bring on biblical Armageddon. Hagee wants the United States to facilitate and fast track taking the world to “end times” and bring on “the rapture” where, according to fundamentalists, true believers will be literally raised into the sky and heaven while the non-believers will be left on earth to live through a hellish nightmare with some antichrist.

Mr. Hagee has become somewhat a folk hero to some Jewish Zionists who seem not to look behind the curtain to see the real man. the persecution of Jews throughout history, and even the Holocaust, was caused by their own “disobedience”. Hagee has written,
“It was the disobedience and rebellion of the Jews, God’s chosen people, to their covenantal responsibility to serve only the one true God, Jehovah, that gave rise to the opposition and persecution that they experienced beginning in Canaan and continuing to this very day… Their own rebellion had birthed the seed of anti-Semitism that would arise and bring destruction to them for centuries to come…. it rises from the judgment of God upon his rebellious chosen people.”

This is a man that Senator McCain sought out for an endorsement. According to a piece to be published in tomorrow’s “New York Times Magazine” and already available on the newspaper’s website Mr. Hagee did not seek out Senator McCain, but instead Mr. McCain sought out Mr. Hagee. This is either poor judgment, a colassal lack of research on this man and his dangerous theology and/or shameful pandering to the religious right in the Republican party.

Mr. Wright may have been a problem for Mr. Obama’s campaign this week, but Mr. Obama superbly and intelligently used the fracas to frankly address the issue of racial divide in this country- a necessary step towards unity. Besides Reverend Wright’s ministry as a whole has been one of social welfare and activism. But Mr. McCain seeking out a hateful man as a supporter with sinister theological motivation for his political leanings is scary at best and naïve at worst.

Finally there was Senator McCain’s comparison of the Jewish holiday Purim to Halloween. Maybe not the biggest mistake he has made- but it sure is worrisome when you look at the litany of gaffes made recently by Senator McCain.

Lieberman once again intervened when McCain made an incorrect reference about the Jewish holiday Purim — by calling the holiday “their version of Halloween here.”

McCain made the incorrect statement during a press conference with Defense Minister Ehud Barak after touring the Israeli city of Sderot to view buildings damaged by Hamas rocket fire. McCain was discussing the numerous rock attacks on the city. “Nine hundred rocket attacks in less than three months, an average of one every one to two hours. Obviously this puts an enormous and hard to understand strain on the people here, especially the children. As they celebrate their version of Halloween here, they are somewhere close to a 15-second warning, which is the amount of time they have from the time the rocket is launched to get to safety. That’s not a way for people to live obviously.”

Purim is not the equivalent of an Israeli Halloween. The holiday — although a joyous one — commemorates a time when the Jewish people living in Persia were saved from mass execution. Halloween was traditionally a celebration of the end of the harvest and one where pagan rituals to scare away evil spirits by dressing in costume became part of the tradition. Later the Catholic Church took it on as All Hallows Eve – the evening before All Saints Day and linked the pagan rituals with ridding evil spirits before the day of the saints.

I think that Esther would have a thing or two about Mr. Mcain’s remarks. Linking a Jewish holiday that commemorates salvation from mass execution to a holiday based in pagan rituals might be somewhat offensive to Esther- and the holiday of Haddassah. Oddly enough Haddassah is Mrs. Lieberman’s name.

Haven’t we seen enough buffonary on the national stage since President Bush took office. Do we need four more years of this sort of international embarassment and shocking lack of understanding the world of diplomacy.

Mr. McCain has no personal understanding of religion- and while his lack of religion doesn’t bother me at all, he is tip toeing through a world where religion matters very much to the dynamics at play in the world- especially in the complicated world of the middle East.

We cannot survive another four years of such colossal misunderstanding of the dynamics at play in the world. We do not need a warrior, even a heroic one, to lead this country to a better place; we need a President who intuitively understands these complicated dynamics and how to address them thoughtfully.

We do not need another President who is constantly misspeaking, doesn’t undersand the real world, and values politics over pandering.


  1. Leon A. Walker March 21, 2008
    Freelance Writer
    Pensacola, Florida

    “Evil Genius?”

    The Republican Party has me absolutely paralyzed with confusion. Perhaps being a lifelong Democrat I am just simply not supposed to understand.

    Being a supporter if Senator Obama I will not cheapen his accedemic accomplishments by making comparisons to those of our current President or his probable future opponnent, Senator John McCain. That would simply be unfair. This all came to mind for me as I recently watched a TV biography of Mr. McCain’s life. The college years I found more than slightly humorous, but also strikingly similar to the college story of George W. Bush. Seemingly both men were accedemically, well… challenged.

    Amid the news clips of preachers, passports and prostitutes this week, there was also Senator McCain stumbling through diplomatic misstatements with repeated and consistent ineptitude. There are those who are suggesting that this was contrived. I almost bit on that, until his “Halloween” comment in Israel. That was the clincher! So as we approach the stretch in the run for the White House, the pride of the Republican Party is providing a telling glimpse ahead.

    Again, I don’t claim to get it, but let me attempt to explain what has me scratching my head. What I see is the Republican party polishing their strategy and preparing for what they hope will be a hard fought contest in November. This, while Senator McCain repeatedly makes an international fool of himself. With an opportunity to look “Presidential” on the world stage, he is singularly cultivating the image of a nervous unprepared student who is unexpectedly called upon to answer a question in class. Then there is poor Joe Lieberman, playing the part of “Monkey In The Middle”. He is like the symathetic friend who finally whispers the correct answer, unable to see his friend suffer in embarassed confusion any longer. Most of the time Senator McCain looks like he could use a nap. Campaigning at this level must certainly be absolutely grueling, and the final contest has yet to begin. At this rate, come November, they will probably have take his straight jacket off just before they drag him out in front of a microphone to utter a few slobbering syllables.

    I don’t have anything against Senator McCain, and given he is an old sailor like me, I can stomach him better than most (dare I say “typical”) Republicans. I’m actually starting to feel some measure of sympathy for the man. As in truth, I predict that he will ultimately face Senator Obama, and that he will lose by the greatest margin in history. Remember you heard it here first.

    Truthfully however, I am genuinely haunted by the following core questions. How does the primary process let this happen? Is this a smoke screen of sorts or is this really the best that the Republicans have to offer? Has the Republican Party become a cheap seedy Oriental Resturant where the only entrée on the menu is “somedumbguy”? Is there a secret Republican Party “Affirmative Action Program” ongoing that provides for letting the stupidest politician among them represent their party from time to time?

    If it were not for the primary elections process I would be envisioning the Republican Party leadership with their ties loosened, drunk out of their skulls in some hotel suite. Then, someone in their group piping up and saying: “let’s give it to McCain” and they all roar in uncontrollable laughter. Then someone says: “Remember Bush?” and the all drop to their knees and roll on the floor, howling and gasping in breathless hysterics.

    Perhaps it possible that the power brokers are intentionally financing and positioning their candidates on the basis of control and future influence? Is it possible that such intellectually and cognitively challenged persons are more easily controlled and manipulated by the Republican Party and its power brokers should they reach the White House? Can it really be that simplistic?

    I don’t get it and I am convinced that I am not supposed to. But am I the only person who is seeing this? Is this just simply my illusion?

    Or is it Republican “evil genius”?

    L. A. Walker

    © Leon A. Walker, March 2008

  2. Leon,

    Gosh I hope you are right about Obama beating the pants off of McCain in a general election. I pray and hope that the American public has had enough of pandering, manipulation through fear and lies and has grown up. To me if Obama is elected- it will give me hope that this country has learned some important lessons. Time will tell if Mr. Obama’s intelligent discussion will resonate with Americans or if most of our fellow citizens still can’t think beyond 2 minute sound bites.

    It is mind boggling that McCain has become Bush Jr. As much as the Republicans would like to say that their base are the Reagan Republicans and the Religious Right- their true base, at least the constituency on who’s behalf they work- are corporate interests. Deregulation, no-bid contracts, trade agreements that reflect corporate interests and a Medicare bill that has nothing to do with Medicare receipients and everything to do with the for profit health mainteinance organizations like the Frist family’s Humana and the pharmaceutical companies.

    It was a Republican, President Dwight D. Eisenhower, who warned us of the dangers of the military industrial complex. Well, fifty years later, his warnings have turned into a disastrous reality- I don’t think that he would have imagined a USA with Haliburton, KBR and Blackwater. Incidentally, Susan Eisenhower- his Republican grand-daughter has endorsed Senator Obama!

  3. When I was a younger man (I use to live in Indiana)I was very interested, troubled, and bothered by the resistance by many Evangelical preachers to their reaction to the plight of RYAN WHITE (He lived in Indiana, a young child with aids during paranoia days of aids who just wanted to go to school) I watched in horror on my grandmothers TV (she loved TBN) as preachers like Pastor John Hagee preached venomously that Ryan White should not be allowed to attend school because he was affected by the DEVILS plague (aids) MY POINT, if the republicans keep wanting to paint Obama’s predicament with Rev. Wright as pertinent; then maybe Democrats need to play many of the Evangelical white preachers like John Hagee’s sermons (Who is supported and accepted into the McCain camp, and been described by McCain as his pastor)about how during the 80s they preached about how aids was evil & that a young boy should not be able to attend school because of being affected with aids, these footages have to be available somewhere…….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: